Rated Good by our guests
Analyze the best time to book Amara Cay Resort in in Islamorada based on 12-month price forecast
I will be returning with my family so me & my wife can get married as well as bring you guys more business!!
Staff were very friendly. Loved the outdoor sitting area with fire pits. Loved the games area on the beach and free kayaks etc. Had dinner and food was incredible.
Amara Cay is centrally located in Islamorada, within easy driving distance of popular Keys attractions: the iconic Robbie’s Marina for tarpon-feeding and local shops; Anne’s Beach for shallow swimming and scenic boardwalks; Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park for geology and short hikes; Theater of the Sea for marine shows and animal encounters; and Founders Park for sports, family-friendly beaches and a playground. The resort’s complimentary shuttle and proximity to Overseas Highway make visiting these nearby spots quick and convenient.
A famous Keys attraction where visitors feed giant tarpon, browse local craft stalls, and book fishing or boat tours.
A popular shallow beach with boardwalks, picnic spots, and calm waters ideal for families and sunset strolls.
A unique state park showcasing exposed fossilized coral reef with short interpretive trails and excellent photo opportunities.
A historic marine park offering dolphin encounters, sea lion and parrot shows, and snorkeling with tropical fish.
Community park with a small beach area, playgrounds, walking paths, sports courts, and year-round events.
A walkable stretch of galleries, boutiques, pop-up markets and cafés showcasing local artists and live music.
A small island archaeological site accessible by boat or kayak with ruins and shallow-water exploration opportunities.
Make the most of your stay at Amara Cay Resort with this convenient itinerary that covers the best attractions in in Islamorada:
Islamorada, in the Upper Florida Keys, is a premier destination for saltwater fishing, snorkeling, relaxed island culture and family-friendly beach time. It combines small-town charm with excellent restaurants, galleries, and outdoor adventures. Amara Cay Resort is a strong choice because it offers oceanfront rooms, family-oriented amenities (free kayaks, games on the beach, shuttle service), praised on-site dining and friendly staff — all in a peaceful setting that keeps you close to Islamorada’s top attractions while still feeling like a getaway.
Amara Cay Resort
80001 Overseas Highway
No essential amenities listed for this property.
Seasonal guide to help you plan the perfect trip to in Islamorada
Winter
Winter (December–April) — dry, mild, popular with northerners seeking warm weather and fishing.
Summer and Fall shoulder months (June–November) — lower lodging rates except around holidays and the Lobster Mini-Season.
March–May: warming temperatures, lower humidity than summer, excellent sportfishing (sailfish/tuna runs pick up), blooms and migratory birds. Expect pleasant days and cooler nights.
Islamorada is famous for sportfishing; tournaments run year-round with peaks in winter and spring for sailfish, and summer tuna events. Local marinas host competitions that draw anglers regionally and nationally.
A statewide short-season lobster opening in July that draws many local and visiting divers and boaters to the Keys. The exact dates are set annually by state wildlife authorities.
Islamorada and other Keys towns commonly host boat parades and holiday festivities in December and early January featuring decorated vessels, music, and community events.
Founders Park and community venues schedule concerts, art shows, and family events especially in summer months and holidays. These are small-community, family-friendly gatherings.
Hurricane season runs June–November, peaking August–September — monitor forecasts and buy travel insurance if traveling then. Summers are hot, humid, and prone to daily thunderstorms; carry reef-safe sunscreen, sun protection, and hydrate. Winters are mild and dry but can have brief cool fronts — pack a light jacket. Be prepared for sudden weather changes when out on the water and always check local marine forecasts before boating.
Islamorada hotel and rental prices fluctuate with fishing seasons, holidays, and school vacation periods. Peak rates occur in winter (holiday travel and 'snowbird' season) and during major fishing tournaments. Summer sees lower nightly hotel base rates but some price increases around the July Lobster Mini-Season and busy holiday weekends. Short-term vacation rentals can be pricey year-round at premium properties; booking 3–6 months ahead is advised for winter travel. Mid-week stays and shoulder seasons (Spring and Fall) often offer the best value.
Insider advice to help you make the most of your visit
Driving the Overseas Highway (US-1) is the most convenient way to reach and move around Islamorada. Boats are essential for many marine activities.
Book fishing charters or popular snorkeling/diving trips well in advance (especially in Winter and Spring). For calmest water and best visibility, plan early-morning excursions. Carry reef-safe sunscreen and a lightweight waterproof jacket for sudden showers; consider a small soft-sided cooler for fresh catches or beach days.
Everything you need to know about your stay at Amara Cay Resort
If you couldn't find the answer to your question, please don't hesitate to contact the hotel directly. Contact Amara Cay Resort directly to confirm reception hours and available assistance.
Optional email after a qualifying drop — free, no credit card